February 2006, download word file, 3 pages Compare And Contrast This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix Arizona. Both revolutions were focused on the countries gaining freedom and independence, mainly looking at the concepts of liberty and equality. The American revolutionists did not intend to start a revolution but to gain freedom Britain. In this respect, both events were revolutions for freedom and share many aspects. The American and French Revolutions are linked in many ways, and this research paper seeks to compare and contrast some of the key elements of both Revolutions. Brief Background Reading on French Revolution3. However it was a minor success because of the socialistic ideologies that were given birth to during the Revolution, which helped reform France into what it is today. Analyzes how the speaker intended to not give us the character's race to prevent the fact that people tend to categorize people. Although the revolutions of both started for very similar reasons, and both countries fought for the same thing, the outcomes of the two were very different. He felt obligated to go, but at the same time he feared going to Arizona because he feared his dad. In the Story, The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven and This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona by Sherman Alexie is about the main character Victor how he encounter challenges about being Native American and poor. Students will use the description chart, then the compare and contrast top hat chart to research the two early settlers in Louisiana and their lasting influences. The main similarity in the French and American Revolution is that commoners were fighting for equality and freedom. This is considered the bloodiest American war in the 18th century. Analyzes how zimmerman believes that alphonse's conviction that all emotions can be trumped by rational appeals to duty and instrumentality caused victor to grow up and act similarly. It took place in . TPT empowers educators to teach at their best. However, when he travelled to claim his fathers body and belongings, the relationship tends to change because, we see him remembering the happy and sad moments they experienced together. robert claims that she and twyla participated, too, in kicking maggie. America wanted to escape from the regulations and rules that the British were putting on them, whereas the French simply wanted to abolish the monarchy in their own country. Analyzes how sherman alexie's short story, "this is what it means to say phoenix, arizona," demonstrates the importance of having past relationships to aid in self-identification. Someone please its for today :(, Changing Americans' Lives 3 votes The Cahier of the Third Estate also stated that the elected officials should only establish the collecting of taxes war movements - USA and Australia United States Nature of Anti-war movements 1. This cross-curricular compare and contrast activity is perfect for the social studies or English classroom and takes about one hour.It includes the following:-A 3-page article about the causes, events, and outcomes American and French Revolutions-A Venn diagram to compare and contrast the revolutions-2 pages of guiding questions for comprehension of the articles content and use of language, Students complete an 11 item graphic organizer with 3 questions to compare and contrast the Revolutionary War and French Revolution. Both of these revolutions were lead by leaders including: George Washington was the commander and chief of the, United States Declaration of Independence. ou, Clerval, my friend, my benefactor (Shelley 129). This enormous massacre of people went against Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity, all of which the national assembly declared were every man 's right. http://media-3.web.britannica.c. The American and French Revolutions were fought several years and an ocean apart. It included people from 3 different continents. Similarly, muskets and artillery were used to attack each other into submission. Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights. World History Bundle for Canadian Students, Effects of the French Revolution and Comparing the American and French Rev. The French Revolution was an important age of political and social turmoil in France that lasted from 1789 to 1799. Although the British won most of the battles, the Americans would be able to form a competent military, with civilian support networks, that provided supplies and financial support (495). The French people were also inspired by the success of American colonists in defeating their British masters. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. In addition, it is evident when Victor shows awkward feelings about his father. The French and Indian War 1754-1763 The French and Indian War extended into the American colonies as an extension of the Seven Years War from Europe. The king did nothing to help the peasants in their times of trouble, which caused even more uproar. One of his main ideas was his political thought on the separation of powers in where each branch of the government would limit the power of the other two branches as so no branch could become a threat to liberty and therefore no tyranny could occur. The first stage of a revolution is the normal stage, a stage in which before the revolution takes place there is a person or group in power, which gained power through traditional means. When the movie begins, Victor is a mean guy, always picking on his cousin, Thomas Builds-the-fire, who was a very sage person, always telling stories. American Revolution. Analyzes how victor's father, who is addicted to alcohol, drives him away from his family, his own son and wife. It effectively began in 1763 when people of the American colonies revolted against the principle of taxation without representation. And also, both started because of enlightenment ideas. comparing revolutions in america and france quizlet. The American Revolution was when the British colonies in America revolted against British rule for being taxed by people not even living on their land and gained independence by overthrowing British imperial rule under King George III. This is significant because both revolutions had this connection. During this time, intellectuals such as Rousseau and Voltaire published influential pamphlets, articles and books which caught the imagination of the general public. Retrieved 19:15, May 01, 2023, from https://www.writework.com/essay/compare-and-contrast-american-and-french-revolutions. Analyzes how victor frankenstein's knowledge and irresponsibility as a tragic hero impacts those around him. Compared with the American Revolution, the French Revolution was more complex, more violent, and far more radical (Spielvogel, p. 329). They will compare and contrast the ideas, thoughts, and arguments expressed in both historical documents and how Enlightenment thought influenced the words within these two monumental works. Analyzes how shakespeare's hamlet and sherman alexie use the theme of father-son relationships to express the personality of his characters. Analyzes how roberta asserts that maggie didn't fall in the orchard, but rather, was pushed by the older girls. Explains that the style of characterization plays a significant role in how the story is told as well as what the reader takes away from it. Also, describing how his relationship with Thomas in Journey has no effect on him. Analyzes how thomas builds-the-fire is born with the special gift to read the future through his intriguing stories in sherman alexie's "this is what it means to say phoenix, arizona.". After all of the blood shed, the laws, civil rights, and codes did not get instituted effectively and did not represent the values that the citizens had fought for. The American revolution and the French Revolution are two major incidents happened in the 1700s, which had intense social impacts on both French and American societies. Web. Although the American and French revolutions were very similar in the actions, there were many differences leading them into ultimately different paths and states of rest. His selfishness and secrecy cause his friends to suffer and also make him a tragic hero within the novel. Analyzes how twyla and roberta are indistinguishable since they are at a young and impressionable age, and have fallen into the same circumstance. Students work in groups to discover the goals, allies, strategies, outcome, and losses/gains for the different parties of the French and Indian War. They no longer believed in the divine rights of Kings and Queens and started believing in the trinity of equality, liberty and fraternity. Analyzes victor's self-identity as a person who chooses his own path by himself, and he does not follow other peoples paths. The main difference is the outcome of the revolutions. The implications of these two revolutions go beyond France and America, for modern electoral democracy effectively began as a consequence. However, problems came up when the nobles refused to sit and discuss with the commoners. American Revolution & French Revolution Activities - 14 Lessons in 1! the romantic movement placed emphasis on individualism and self-expression across literature, art and music. Thomas Hutchinson, the royal governor of Massachusetts at the time, sums the reason for war best, saying "No middle ground exists between the supreme authority of Parliament and the total dependence of the colonies: it is impossible there should be two independent legislatures in one and the same state'" (Van Tyne 135). The countries fought different battles. Pre-Revolutionary France - Three Estates Chart5. thomas' change is subtle, but it is there. England also played a big part in influencing both nations but it was the famous philosophers like Montesquieu, Rousseau, John Lock and Voltaire who lead the revolution to be a fight for human rights. The French Revolution followed in suit with the American Revolution, because the French were in favor for what the American Revolution was fighting for. They brought their biological weapons reasearch with them. Analyzes how lee zimmerman, author of frankenstein, invisibility and the nameless dread, uses many resources to explain multiple theories on the novel. On the, Since both France and America had the same philosophers to influence them, they were ?enlightened? This activity is an interactive internet scavenger hunt. The handout provides links to various parts of the pbs.org American Revolution website that sutdents will explore to answer questions. Although the ideas of the American and French Revolutions where similar, they are not the same. The Declaration of Independence was basically announcing them as not the thirteen colonies but as the first thirteen states of the U.S. Montesquieu was a French jurist and political philosopher who advocated a ?free and balanced aristocratic government? Analyzes how the movie, smoke signals, portrays what being a native american really means. Students will share their findings with the class and complete a graphic organizer comparing the British, French, Colonists, and Native Americans. Looking deeper into the events surrounding the French Revolution shows that there are striking similarities with its American counterpart; both America and France were becoming dissatisfied with their absolute monarchy, poverty and taxation bringing citizens to a boiling point. The success of the American Revolution, in turn, inspired certain French planters and merchants in Saint-Domingue. his father, arnold joseph, saved both of the boys, but could not save thomas's parents. As a result, the Americans were looking for independence.The French Revolution, on the other hand, was centered on putting an end to the monarchy and implementing a new style of government while also changing the social structure which favored the hereditary elites. American Revolution vs. French Revolution Is There a Difference? After French King Louis XVI was tried and executed on January 21, 1793, war between France and monarchal nations Great Britain and Spain was inevitable. In the same manner, the muskets and artillery were used to attack each other into submission. In this unit, you examined the American and French Revolutions. The French began the Tennis Court Oath, the Storming of the Bastille, and the overthrown of Monarchy. Both the French and American Revolution had their own declarations and constitutions written. Copyright 2000-2023. Activity to compare French and American Revolutions 4. Both the commoners and the clergys were angered, they went together to form the National Assembly of France. to seven-sentence paragraph that answers these Explains that victor gave thomas half of his father's ashes as a gift for helping him out. The Enlightenment was a movement by intellectuals who promoted reason and science, and they began to question the system in place at the time in France and they began to spread revolutionary ideas that got people thinking about change. The American Revolution was effectively a "conservative" advancement, and was fought, Compare And Contrast The French And American Revolution, The French and American Revolution had similar goals, and were caused by the lack of the same things. The revolutions were similar because they both wanted a different ruler and they both had absolute monarchs. This move further alienated the colonists and primed their thoughts for independence. Here is a breakdown of whats included:American Revolution Visual TimelineAmerican vs. French Revolution WorksheetFrench Revolution Notes student copy includedFrench Revolution QuestionnaireAmerican and French Revolution Compare and Contrast PaperNapoleon Story BoardsRevolutions Study GuideRevolutions Jeopardy GameEurope Post-Congress of Vienna NotesPost- Napoleonic Europe Alp, This graphic organizer is dedicated to the causes of the French Revolution, and it includes a key. Both countries were trying to gain freedom. In particular, the exercise compares the American, French, and Haitian Revolutions and seeks to explore to what extent these revolutions were "revolutionary." A stamp glued to each article indicated that the tax had been paid. America had much more military than France in their revolution. It might be asked why Roosevelt did not plot the fall of the British Empire as well. The goals of both of these are different for a reason, because the French Revolution wanted a government and the American Revolution wanted to get away from their government. During the late 18th century, America a country ruled by The United Kingdom, had no control of the thirteen colonies. Summarize and compare and contrast the English Bill of Rights, the Cahier of the 3rd Estate and Common Sense. The American and the French revolutions had many similarities and differences. In France, the people were divided into three separate social estates, clergy, nobility, and the commoner as the lowest and the highest above all of course would be the king. The revolutions of France and North America were extremely relevant yet not necessarily helpful to the commoners, and their liberty and equality. Victors dad explains to Thomas, Take care of each other (516). In comparison, the first instances of declaring independence were used, not seen in the magnitude that they were declared before. It can increase the efficiency of decisio This revolution eventually inspired others throughout the world as it was successful in gaining the colonies independence from a powerful European empire. During the 1770s and 1780s, these men frequently demanded freer trade, sometimes through violent revolt. Examples of this were the Napoleonic Code and Declaration of Rights of Man. In spite of all the similarities, the American Colonists had uniforms and the French did not. Why is it important for citizens to have a say in their g Choose the definition that fits the way in which the word is used in the sentence. Both countries were trying to gain freedom. This is significant because the American colonists probably had more time to prepare for an invasion and in addition, the country Britain was far away from America. Though both revolutions have many relations, they both have many dissimilarities, throughout my work I will be displaying the reasons why both revolutions were similar and why they are different. However Victor was a young boy his father left him. However, only American Revolution was able to sustain the democracy gained by such as vast revolution. But since the fire, Arnold has carried guilt on his soul, and was using alcohol to suppress the memory, he would constantly intoxicate himself. During the Revolution many events occurred having a major effect, such as the sugar act, currency act, and the Townshend act. American Revolution and Haitian Revolution4. Maggie, however, we cannot determine her racial status. While waiting Victors dad picked him up, bought him a dinner, and returned him home. A cynical answer to this is that Roosevelt understood that the United States state governments, charitable donors, and the United States Vietnamese as well as many Vietnamese-Americans. Section 1 and 2 guided notes template 3. The third estate created the Declaration of the rights of man and of the citizen to express these goals. Those revolutions include the Haitian and French Revolution. With the weight of heavy taxation, like the stamp act and the tea tax, pared with Britains decision to tax the colonists without an elected representative in parliament, American had set its sights on a democratic representative type of governing (Our Human History, pg. The Americans and French both had a normal stage in which they were ruled by and monarchs were chosen in a traditional way. Pre-Revolutionary Colonial Society Chart4. At the time King Louis XVI was the French king and had power from 1774 to 1792 and was later executed in 1793. Analyzes how thomas is an odd character, a lonely and sad person at heart. Similarities : - The French Revolution and American Revolution are similar. ADVERTISEMENT One of them is the fact that the American's had warships and the French rebels did not. Just like in every warring country, it is inevitable that there will be some change that occurs whether it be for the better or for worse. The French Revolution leaves a noble mark in history where peasants of a lower class claimed their rights from a corrupt system of monarchs and social hierarchy. America. In many ways, the causes for which the French were fighting resembled that of the American colonists. This makes Victor to be a modern character who only think about himself. French documents regarded taxes. One similarity being is that they both wanted to escape the rule of their King. Outcomes of Revolution Comparison C, This is a complete multi-day lesson that's perfect for wrapping up a unit on the American and French revolutions. Both countries won their revolutions. Opines that by using a new path from modern way it is possible to bring an old tradition to the future and discover the whole new answers. Moment before his death he turns to Captain Robert Walton and says, I feel myself justified in desiring the death of my adversary. WriteWork contributors. The death of the monster would not even weigh on his conscience since it is gods. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. Analyzes how twyla and roberta are the only children at the orphanage who still have their parents. he knew that if he had to talk to someone it could be victor. This sample comparative essay explores the historical origins of each revolution and analyzes the aftermath of each one. It can help citizens feel more connected to the government. The French Revolution and American Revolution were the instances of civilians rebelling against their government. They demonstrated pure democracy by abolishing the 3 estates and assuming power for the people. The American lifestyle is fast-paced and focused on work/career success. Moreover, during this time, Victor is able to reclaim what was good and bad about his father and his feelings change little bit, because Alexie says that after adding up the memories of his father, he smiled. After all both American and French Revolution took place about the same time. The French and American revolutions are both very significant in the worlds history. Analyzes how victor frankenstein and his creature are tormented by humanity and become criminals, but does this necessarily mean that both were unable to retain their humanity? As to the American revolution was more conservative and federal. They are similar because the people rebelled were ordinary citizens taking up arms and attacking their governments. This allows the readers to see how powerful a friendship could be in just short, Click here to unlock this and over one million essays, Thomass vision helps Victor realize how his father truly feels about his family. The American and French Revolution both had similar stages that a revolution consists of having a normal stage, widespread dissatisfaction, and the transfer of power and effect. In the second story, Victor or the narrator talks more in depth about how it is being Native American in a foreign land. He decided to ask him to lend him some money for his fathers cremation. OD. Both French Revolution and American Revolution succeeded in toppling the monarchy. the cycle of life and death that they discussed had similar meanings as the past and present, and also future. The stamp tax levied taxes on commercial and legal documents, such as, diplomas, pamphlets, newspapers, almanacs, dice, and playing cards. NoiseeShoes,High School, 11th grade,A, Some were Britain's treasury was drained so they taxed America and angered the colonists, similar to the French treasury being low, so they declared war on other countries to try to refill the treasury. Analyzes how victor becomes obsessed with vengeance when the monster frankenstein created spurs him. Road to Revolution Comparison Chart6. The activity may be completed independently is assigned via Google Classroom or as a group assignment by setting up learning stations.This product includes the following:1. How Do These Foundational Documents Compare? These graphic organizers will ensure students stay focused and have clear criteria to research. It was at this juncture that the famous Boston Tea Party happened. End of the year review for Early American History Wars Include:French & Indian WarAmerican RevolutionWar of 1812Mexican American WarCivil WarThe learners will compare the wars that the United States took part in (French & Indian War, American Revolution, War of 1812, Mexican American War, and Civil War) by correctly categorizing 16 descriptions for each one. Victor represents the modern people because people from the present always think about themselves and does not care about the past, so money that victors father had was very important to Victor to live his life. Previously in the novel he blamed himself for the deaths of Mathew, Justine, and Henry, claiming to be their murderer and lamenting on the evil he had set forth into the world. However, The American Revolution involved a colonial uprising against an, The French and American Revolutions were significant revolutionary movements that essentially played a vital role in shaping modern nations. In order to pay the it off, the king, Louis XIV, levied a large tax, however the people refused to pay. The British enforced the Stamp Act on the Americans. Question 6 of 20 Concert of EuropeThe key to the graphic organizerA venn diagram to compare the American and French RevolutionsA key to the venn diagram comparing the American and French Revoluti. Victors father, Arnold Joseph, saved both of the boys from a fire that he involuntarily started on the 4th of July when the boys were babies. need asap I also need to be explained really well please I need more, The idea of democracy is often what people say sets America apart from many other They both had a time when both sides oppressed the French and British government. Though Thomass stories often annoy Victor, he gives a specific story that makes Victor realize his fathers intentions. The people no longer marched in blasting away at each other. As I read the story of Toni Morrison the young girl Twyla in the story felt lonely and depressed how her mother was a dancer and she was living in St. Bonny's in an Orphan shelter. Both revolutions were connected to each other because of the link between France and Haiti, known then as St Domingue. The English Bill of Rights declared that there would be no more collecting of taxes without the permission of the Parliament. Brief Background Reading on American Revolution2. Almost all revolutions in history have these stages but the details are almost always different. The revolution in America preceded that in France by a decade or so. Both wanted to set up a Republic, which provided liberty and justice to all classes of citizens. The lower class had had it, the rebellions had begun. His smiling was an indication that at least he had found peace that was never there in the relationship with his, Victor finally accepts the fact that his father is gone; He searched his mind for memories of his father, found the good ones, found a few bad ones, added it all up, and smiled (516). Which do you think changed Wars, American and French Revolutions Google Slides - Compare and Contrast, American and French Revolutions Compare & Contrast - World History, AP European History Per. in the movie, he tells thomas to not be fooled by others. Not having seen his father in a couple of years and finding out that he has died would hit anyone hard. victor, the main character and narrator, talks about his father's relationship with him and his mother. He was waiting for a vision, or a sign from the dream. How? 2023. These revolutions were similar in a way, because they both were fighting against their suppressing powers and one difference was the way that unity shaped the way they gained independence. Just like France, the American colonists were composed up mainly middle and lower class citizens. There is a third character in Recitatif who gives distortion of Robertas and Twylas memories. There was a common cause, goal, and effect of each of these three revolutions in addition to the unique causes, goals, and effects. Victor felt a sudden need for tradition (Alexies). Their fury was such that they made sure that the last floating crate of tea was duly sunk into the saline ocean waters. The sentence in this exercise contains an italicized word beginning with one of the three prefixes. Likewise, the American Revolution was also a political and social upheaval that took place from 1765 to 1783, where the colonists in the thirteen colonies rejected the British rule and were eventually able to defeat Britains authority hence creating the United States of America. Students will examine primary sources to learn more about each revolution. Narrates how victor was in denial about his father passing away, and everything that suzy had told him. French The majority of the people did not want the revolution (American, French, or Both?) Opines that mary shelley's frankenstein is a wonderful story that has been slowly destroyed by hollywood through the years. he tells victor of his father's perishing love and provides victor closure. In 1789, 5 years after helping the Americans fight their revolution, the French were in the midst of an economic collapse that was worsened by Louis. He even begins to lose the small amount of compassion he had for the creatures struggle. Study notes on the conflict in indo-china (Aust syllabus), Vietnam War: April 30th 1975 The Most Remembered Day of the War, The Role of Education and the Military in Sparta.